VL concept theory

X-V8L

This is X-V8L flight model developed using X-Plane
On this page, I will try to explain why this thing flies and why is it supposed to fly better than MC15 Cricket which has almost the same characteristics (twin engines, wing area, weight). Of course, the new idea is it's wing; rest of the components (propellers, wheels, avionics, canopy, pilot and so on) can be found in anything that flies :)


Remark: what does "X-V8L" means? "X" is from eXperimental, of course. "VL"? "V" is the shape of front wing, and "L" is the shape of back wing. Aaaahm? Russian "L", what is: "/\". Now, use your imagination to find what part of design reminds "8" in shape 8-)




Introduction

First of all, I'll remind you of today's most common airplane schematics. I'll also try to briefly (very briefly!) point pros & cons of each scheme. So, here we go:
  1. Flying Wing - Although this one seems to be the most simple, well, it's actually not. It's aerodynamics are close to ideal, only lift and almost no drag... But it's unstable and difficult to handle as control surfaces are relatively close to CG. Thus flying wings are uncommon; few of them that actually do fly (like this "B-2") are usually equipped with artificial stability resources. Lift vector (represented as green arrow below) is right above Center of Gravity (represented as funny yellow/black ball).

    Flying Wing scheme

  2. Conventional - As it's very name says it's the most common scheme. This happens to this scheme's high stability and easy handling. But nothing is perfect, and the price of it's stability is... Well, look at figure below. CG is a bit in front of wing lift vector. So, wing is pulling up and airplane's nose is pulling down. To solve that there is horizontal stabilizer pulling airplane's tail down to compensate wing-CG moment. Simple and stable, but not very efficient aerodynamically, as engine wastes it's power producing 2 opposite vectors that are subtracted.

    Conventional scheme

  3. Canard - No, this isn't just conventional scheme backwards :)
    First planes like "14-bis" and "Wright Flyer" were conventionals backwards but then designers noticed that forward configuration is much more stable. So, why does it still exists? Today's canards are different. Take a look at this "Long-EZ" by Burt Rutan. Both wing and horizontal stabilizer produces lift. CG is now located between wings (yes, now stabilizer acts as wing!) right in the place where front wing lift moment compensates back wing one. This makes canard much more stable but it is still more difficult to handle than conventional airplane.

    Canard scheme





VL concept

So, what exactly VL scheme is? Nothing more than hybrid of biplane, canard and... flying wing. What makes me think so:

VL scheme

Both front and back wings of VL scheme create almost the same lift, so CG is exactly at middle of them. I say "almost the same" because if it were same the airplane's natural behavior would be "climb until stall", and we want something that flies horizontally thus front wing has lower incidence and CG itself is a bit in front of middle point.

And here come promised illustrations of ring, joined and box wings (click on pictures to follow to original context sites):

Ring Wing scheme Joined Wing scheme Box Wing scheme
Ring wing concept (montage) Joined wing concept by Jose E. Araya Box wing concept by Lockheed Martins

Of course, my X-V8L looks like "joined wing" airplane. But strangely, I did not even knew about existence of such idea until I started to write this text (at this point I'm yet another "bicycle inventor" who could save a lot of time just seeking in Google :)

My primary thought was to design a ring wing which could fly with no stabilizers and neither fuselage. But "smooth" ring wing is very complex even to be drawn (airfoils "morph" between top, sides and bottom). Also ring wing alone is not stable, it needs extra surfaces to give it stability. You can see stabilizers on every one of 3 similar concepts from above.

VL has approach a bit different from ring wing: instead of smooth cylindrical wing it is composed by 4 surfaces composing 3D parallelogram. This makes the structure itself very robust and able to handle heavy G-load... Or allows one to use lighter and thinner (and less expensive!) materials to build such airplane. Also, when you decompose lift vectors of 4 surfaces you see that VL wing by itself has everything to keep it stable on 3 axes; so it doesn't need stabilizers and neither anything else to fly well!

Thus I frequently refer to X-V8L fuselage as "gondola"; it's 100% utilitary structure with only purpose to carry the payload (pilot). If specific X-V8L case it also holds wings from escaping and two engines with counter-rotating propellers. I firstly thought to put engines at tips of wings so changing propellers pitch would give yaw control but it seems that this concept applies much better to jets.




Analogs

Ligeti Stratos Ikelos
Ligeti Stratos Virginia Tech & Loughborough University Ikelos

Lots of thanks to Graham Addis to gather out these beautiful planes on the Internet!

As I said before, I had no knowledge about these planes when I started drawing first VLs on paper sheets. AFAIK, they're patented designs, and Stratos layout dates back to 1982 (Ikelos dates 2001 which is later to my very first box wing idea but I started my real efforts to "research" at 2003 so it's older also :)

The main difference between my VL concept and these box-wings is that both Stratos & Ikelos still have vertical stabilizers. This adds more surface joins and consequently weakens box structure. Thus VL concept uses other approach: dihedral is bigger and the structure is perfectly symmetrical in 3 axes. My supposition is that aerodynamic force vectors from dihedral wings will give enough yaw stability so dedicated structure will only increase the drag. And yaw control can be obtained by thrust vector scheme, thus why VL is both bi-motor and duct-fan.

I hope that differences are enough to not to claim "know-how", and this way I expect to build VL concept-based prototype one day :)




Advantages?




Disadvantages?